Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Britain's infamous and ancient Antisemitism

I'm British and it's not infamous enough for me to have heard of it.



If you can't see it in your country's current actions, I don't know what to say.

For the historical, start with e.g. this in 1144 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_libel#Middle_Ages and for more recent, read up on how at almost every turn Churchill's efforts to help Jews during WWII were thwarted by those under him.


I don't deny that there is bigotry in Britain, including bigotry against Jews. (Of course there is: there is bigotry everywhere).

What I do question is that there was/is more of it in Britain than in other countries. For example, the part of Britain I live in (Scotland) is the only European country never to have had state persecution of Jews. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_in_Scotlan...)

> for more recent, read up on how at almost every turn Churchill's efforts to help Jews during WWII were thwarted by those under him.

If someone asked me to name a country that was "infamous" for anti-semitism during WW2, I doubt if Britain is the one that would spring to mind. Nor would it for most historians.


Ah, I know nothing about Scottish Antisemitism or a lack thereof, and I wouldn't be surprised to know it's different than England.

Your latter point is a bit of a cheap shot; of course we all know which country was "infamous" in WWII; what's interesting is the counties other than that one. E.g. look at the percentage of Jews who survived in occupied ones, factoring in the differences in the occupations. And which ones accepted refugees and to what extent. Then there's the war policies, and there to a very great extent the U.K. called the shots in the Western European Theater. That's where I'm suggesting one look ... although of course it's not something that can be quantified, seeing as it was the only combatant after the fall of France.


> Your latter point is a bit of a cheap shot; of course we all know which country was "infamous" in WWII

Indeed. But your phrase was "Britain's infamous antisemitism". I was pointing out that British antisemitism during WW2 was in fact not "infamous". Indeed, if the worst thing that Britain did during WW2 wasn't harming Jews but not helping them as much as some people in the UK government would have liked, then they couldn't really have been very anti-semitic, could they?

In Britain, it is illegal to discriminate against someone because they are Jewish, and has been for several decades. Furthermore, of Britain's two largest political parties, one has a Jewish leader and the other did from 2003-2005; it is unlikely that either party would have done this if it thought a Jewish leader would be an electoral liability, or if their rank-and-file members disliked Jews. Are these the actions of a country "infamous" for antisemitism?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: