Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

the author seems to miss the _reason_ for the discrepancies in diagrams, its not the tool, persay, its the lack of knowledge. In a big system its not really that plausible to know the whole system.

The author _almost_ grasps this, but instead of thinking why teams might not know the "truth" of a system, they dive straight into code. sure great, having UML is great, but I can guarantee that nobody apart from the author is going to update it, because the barrier to entry is a fucktonne higher than using some web based visio clone.

If you want an accurate diagram, that self updates, then you need a tool that pulls the relationships out and generates it. However this will be messy, difficult to understand and possibly fragile. Worse still, unless you are lucky, it will be a custom tool.

However, given that most people recognise that you need to monitor your service in depth, its not actually that hard to generate a dependency map from your monitoring system, if you've set it up properly.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: