I'm not sure if it's because my tolerance of Graham Linehan has snapped or not, but I barely laugh at the IT Crowd any more. As with other GL shows I find it's just mostly held together but the cast's delivery and such
The laugh track and the writing is honestly dated even by the standards of Dads Army.
I don't remember the details, but I think that season 2 kind of retroactively ruined season 1. They used to have all those O'Reilly and EFF stickers, and working at a help desk at the time, it felt very authentic. Then everything got super nice in season 2 -- leather couches, people were dressing nicely, etc. It kind of lost its charm. You can't rewatch it because you know Denholm is just going to randomly jump out of a window.
(Having said that, I think "Fire" was a memorable episode that is still amusing. The 0118911881999119 song, "it's off, so I'll turn it on... AND JUST WALK AWAY".)
It might have been ahead of its time. Silicon Valley was well received and is as nerdy and intricately detailed as Season 1 of the IT Crowd. "Normal people" thought it was far out and zany. People that work in tech have been to all those meetings. And, a major character was named PG!
> They used to have all those O'Reilly and EFF stickers, and working at a help desk at the time, it felt very authentic. Then everything got super nice in season 2 -- leather couches, people were dressing nicely, etc. It kind of lost its charm.
That sounds like a pretty realistic allegory of the last two decades in Free Software (or software in general, or the web...)
The IT Crowd's comedy became dated incredibly quickly, just like Father Ted's.
Comedies that came later ditched the laugh track. They had to work harder to get viewers at home to laugh, but ultimately a bunch of them (starting with The UK Office) hold up much better as a result.
The laugh track and the writing is honestly dated even by the standards of Dads Army.