Perhaps, but here's a personal anecdote when I was interviewed years ago. The interviewer asked me one of the trick problems popular at the time, which I knew the answer to. Ironically, it was not a problem I'd studied for; I just happened to have seen in elsewhere years prior, found it interesting, so I remembered it and its solution. To be clear, I didn't solve the problem the first time I'd seen it, either.

Nevertheless, I gave the interviewer a detailed, step-by-step, golden answer she was looking for, and she's obliviously impressed. After a few minutes, however, youthful stupidity^W^Wmy integrity got the better of me and I told her that I'd seen the problem before. So I got a 2nd trick problem, one that I didn't know nor studied for, and naturally didn't arrive at the golden solution.

I didn't get called back.

If you were to ask me to solve a problem that's on my study list today, believe me that I've got the selling part down pat now.