Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

As a user, I can't stand amp -- issues are 1.) no link to original site. 2.) top banner plague 3.) weird smooth scrolling that messes with my muscle memory.

There are two workarounds to avoid amp all together: 1.) use DDG and prefix all queries with "!g" or 2.) visit encrypted.google.com that does not use amp.

Given that I tend to stay on a page for 2-10 minutes, shaving off 1sec is less than 0.8% improvement. This is not worth it given the horrible drawbacks and UX.



>2.) top banner plague

the top banner is something that Google adds, and isn't, strictly speaking, part of AMP.


Is there any use of AMP which isn't driven by Google? I've never seen it referenced except in Google search results.



Well, you can access the AMP version of the page from anywhere, not just Google search results. I could see apps that use an in-app browser serving the AMP version of a page, instead of the full version, for instance. I guess we'll see?


I'm aware that it's technically possible but was realizing that, as a fairly active mobile web user, I had never noticed AMP in use except for Google search results.


i could see other apps that use a native browser preferring the AMP version. something like yelp, that lets you click through to the source page, for instance.


I get AMP pages via the Facebook app quite often


Those are Instant Articles - Facebook's version of AMP, but not AMP itself.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: