Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's only a tax in the very narrow sense that it keeps prison officers and policemen in jobs. I want the money to go towards general taxation. In Britain some £6bn is spent on cannabis each year. Taking a third of that in tax raises enough to reverse half of the chancellor's very controversial recent cuts to tax credits.


Where does the £6b number come from? It seems very high to me.

A 2014 survey has the following numbers: 31% have ever used illegal drugs, 21% still take illegal drugs "even if only occasionally". 93% of people who have tried illegal drugs have tried weed. [1]

Let's say the UK population is 65 million, that makes 13.65m "occasional or more often" illegal drug users, and if we assume that all of the 93% of those who have tried weed still smoke weed, that's 12,694,500 weed smokers. So with that number, to hit a total spend of £6B they would be spending an average of £472 each, or £9/week - I guess that's about 0.5-1g/week. I could believe that amount as an average among "weed smokers", but given the number includes people who say they do it "only occasionally", I suspect the long-tail means that £6b is unrealistically high.

That said, if you have a source for that I'd be interested to see more info.

[1] http://www.theguardian.com/society/2014/oct/05/-sp-drug-use-...


I tracked this down eventually (took a while, sorry!) The number comes from a Home Office report:

http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20110220105210/rds...

However that's up to 6.6 billion for the whole illegal drugs market (not just cannabis). So the figure for cannabis would be much lower (see also that report).


Thanks - and OK, for all drugs makes a lot more sense to me.


Why would you need more tax revenues from this economic activity? To fund addiction treatment programs?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: